Thursday, February 24, 2022
THURSDAY BACKTRACK: Music and news from 60 years ago - week ending 24 February 1962
Wednesday, February 23, 2022
Ukraine: do we need the War Game? by Sackerson
In this context the Daily Mail is to be commended for going
ahead and publishing Peter Hitchens’ article https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-10540829/PETER-HITCHENS-blame-arrogant-foolish-West-Ukraine-crisis.html
castigating the West for its arrogance and folly in continuing to treat Russia
as an enemy after the fall of Communism; though even the mighty Mail feels
compelled to push it back into page 13 of the print edition and label it ‘A
personal viewpoint.’ Somehow one senses masks and disposable gloves.
If you rely on the mass media you could be forgiven for
thinking that Russia’s tanks and troops are already rolling into the Donbass;
not so, according to a well-connected blogger https://therealslog.com/2022/02/23/exclusive-no-putin-invasion-of-ukraine/
who quotes a French diplomat as saying to him (Tuesday 22 Feb):
‘It is now clear that there have
been Russian peacekeeping troops in the Donbass for at least five years. Their
presence there has been maintained. Putin has signed a decree allowing for
further troops to go there, but there is no NATO evidence as yet that any
new troops have arrived.’
On the other hand, as The Independent reported back in
December https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/russia-ukraine-army-donbass-troops-b1967532.html
, Ukraine by then had already positioned half its army on the other side of the
conflict zone – some 125,000 troops. One wonders how one of the poorest countries
in Europe https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/gdp-per-capita-ppp?continent=europe
can afford to maintain a standing army a quarter-million strong and bombard its
eastern populace for seven years rather than implement the Minsk Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minsk_agreements#Minsk_Protocol
to split the country into autonomous regions. We could do with some quality
mainstream journalism.
Speaking of the latter, as tensions mount it is disappointing
to hear from the recently-freed Craig Murray https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2022/02/ukraine-where-to-find-the-truth-in-enormous-detail/
(appeal against alleged miscarriage of Scottish justice ongoing) that the
independent team of observers known as OSCE, specified in the same Protocol,
has just been abandoned by the USA, UK and Canada, three Western members of the
Five Eyes intelligence alliance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Eyes
, at the time when they are most needed. OSCE was not allowed to access the
site of the kindergarten shelled last week, allegedly a false flag attack by
the eastern Ukrainians themselves, though according to another independent
journalist, the intrepid Eve Bartlett, the munition was fired from an ‘American
M141 bunker-type grenade launcher’ from the west. https://ingaza.wordpress.com/2022/02/18/ukraine-appears-to-have-staged-a-kindergarden-attack-to-cover-its-crimes-fuel-anti-donbass-propaganda/
Doubtless there are several drivers behind these murky
goings-on. One will be Russian politics post the Soviet collapse, which will
have left many Russians suddenly finding themselves effectively stranded in
countries no longer part of the communist empire. President Putin’s rewritten
Constitution in 2020 empowers Russia to defend its citizens abroad https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/belarusalert/putins-new-constitution-spells-out-modern-russias-imperial-ambitions/
; at the risk of attracting Mr Dale’s ire I might cite Britain’s similar
approach in the past – the War of Jenkins' Ear https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_Jenkins%27_Ear
, the robust defence of the Falkland Islanders ( who were technically not even
British citizens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Nationality_(Falkland_Islands)_Act_1983
) and so on. We remain to be convinced that Putin simply has a plan for
European domination; past history shows the traffic has sometimes been the
other way.
Another factor is the longstanding US/NATO policy of Russian
containment, first urged by George Kennan in 1946. https://digitalarchive.wilsoncenter.org/document/116178.pdf
This made sense when the USSR was indeed what Reagan called an ‘evil empire’;
the pity is that even when the battle had been won by the West – in 1989
Yeltsin was ‘sick with despair for the Soviet people’ and knew the end was near
when he saw the cornucopia of a Texan supermarket https://www.nhregister.com/neighborhood/bayarea/news/article/When-Boris-Yeltsin-went-grocery-shopping-in-Clear-5759129.php
- the policy continued. Five years after the collapse, President Carter’s
former adviser Zbigniew Brzeziński wrote a book on American
geostrategy https://www.cia.gov/library/abbottabad-compound/36/36669B7894E857AC4F3445EA646BFFE1_Zbigniew_Brzezinski_-_The_Grand_ChessBoard.doc.pdf
in which he worried that
‘… any ejection of America by its
Western partners from its perch on the western periphery would automatically
spell the end of America's participation in the game on the Eurasian
chessboard, even though that would probably also mean the eventual
subordination of the western extremity to a revived player occupying the middle
space.’
25 years on, after President Trump had told European NATO
allies to shoulder more of the burden of their defence https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jul/11/donald-trump-tells-nato-allies-to-spend-4-of-gdp-on-defence
, we face that possibility. Now, it seems to be about containing, not lethally
expansionary Communism, but a nascent power bloc in eastern Europe, a sort of
Eurasian EU https://www.theguardian.com/world/shortcuts/2014/feb/18/brief-primer-vladimir-putin-eurasian-union-trade . Is it our business to prevent that, at much
expense of blood and treasure? Should we have outgrown Great Game-playing in
the new era of potential nuclear global destruction?
Ukraine is an awkwardly complex corner of Brzeziński’s
chessboard: the Washington Post illustrated its long history in 2015 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/03/09/maps-how-ukraine-became-ukraine/
and here is a simplified overview (reproduced
on MoA https://www.moonofalabama.org/2022/02/some-bits-on-ukraine.html)
:
The sudden changes brought about by the defeat of the Red
Menace has presented challenges for everyone and we should proceed with
caution. The area around the Black Sea has changed radically: in 1988 it was
practically a Red lake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comecon#/media/File:Europe_1988.svg
, except for the shores of eastern Greece and northern Turkey; in recent years,
NATO allies have started to encircle it and if Ukraine joins up the lake will
be largely Blue. NATO members have permitted the siting of weapons closer and
closer to Russia’s western borders; the Great Game here is almost like the
children’s game of ‘What’s The Time, Mister Wolf?’ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What%27s_the_time,_Mr_Wolf%3F
Is it necessary?
Is it affordable? Perhaps when we bemoan the state of our
economy, of the NHS and the meanness of our State pension system compared with
those in the EU, we should remember how WWI impoverished the UK – the Twenties
did not roar in Britain - and WWII very nearly bankrupted us completely. We’ve
been struggling against headwinds ever since 1914.
Sixty years ago, Dean Acheson told West Point that ‘Great
Britain has lost an empire and has not yet found a role.’ https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/acref/9780191843730.001.0001/q-oro-ed5-00000015
It’s time to grow up and not be anybody’s playground sidekick, unless it is in
our national interest.
THURSDAY BACKTRACK: Music and news from 60 years ago - week ending 17 February 1962
The famous dog show started in 1891 and has been held annually since then, apart from some of the years in the two World Wars.
13 February: 'A crowd of between 150,000 and 500,000 people marched in Paris in the first massive protest against the continuing Algerian war, which had gone into its eighth year. The occasion was the funeral ceremony for five of the nine people who had been killed by police in the Charonne metro station the previous Thursday. With many of the participants walking off of their jobs to protest, business in Paris and much of France was brought to a halt.'
Monday, February 21, 2022
Five fine things found on Facebook (4)
Sunday, February 20, 2022
The real battle, by Sackerson
It’s not about fighting Communism - the battle against the
USSR was won in the 1990s.
Or are we to be persuaded by racialism? It’s worked before: see the WWI US recruiting poster by Harry Hopps, where a drooling monster ape in a German Pickelhaube helmet holds a despairing young woman – boobs out, lads, look! – under the title ‘Destroy This Mad Brute.’
Today the target is not the Hun but the Slav, appealing to what Peter Hitchens has just called ‘the ridiculous cartoon idea that Russia is like Mordor in Lord Of The Rings, an utterly evil country ruled by a Dark Monster.’ https://hitchensblog.mailonsunday.co.uk/2022/02/peter-hitchens-granny-gets-her-gun-from-a-bunch-of-shamelss-neo-nazis-not-that-the-bbc-would-ever-te.html Do Slav lives matter?
Our propaganda may be as crude as that of a century ago – see
last Friday’s Mail article describing President Putin as a ‘Snarling rat backed
into a corner’ https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-10525223/Vladimir-Putin-snarling-rat-backed-corner-writes-IAN-BIRRELL.html - but the quality of our politicians actually seems to have declined.
Think of our Foreign Secretary, who can’t distinguish between the Baltic and
the Black Sea https://www.dailymail.co.uk/video/vladimirputin/video-2604297/Video-Liz-Truss-confuses-Baltic-Black-Sea-700-miles-apart.html
and goes into a meeting with Mr Lavrov unaware that Rostov and Voronezh are
Russian regions https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/kremlin-cites-truss-error-evidence-west-doesnt-understand-ukraine-conflict-2022-02-11/
If she wishes to channel Mrs Thatcher she should imitate Maggie’s diligent preparation.
Perhaps our representatives are counting on the dumbing-down
of a populace whose imagination has been fed by the fascistic violence of Marvel
comic heroes and a secular religion figureheaded by an autistic teenage
activist I call the Swedish Frightingale or Joan of Aargh.
Are we fighting for democracy? Let’s not look too closely at
how the current regime in Ukraine was installed. For that matter, is the EU a
democracy? If it is, why did we leave?
Is the UK a democracy? Actually, no; we have a constitutional
monarchy and are subjects not citizens. When John Dunning proposed his 1780
motion to curb the influence of the Crown https://libquotes.com/john-dunning/quote/lbj9i1o
he may have thought that Parliament was belling the cat; instead, power has
simply passed down to the Privy Council, of which the PM and all the Cabinet
are automatically members. Tony Benn, a socialist but a Parliamentarian to his
bootstraps, warned many years ago - and I'm sorry not to have found a link -
that our freedoms could be swept away in an afternoon by Order In Council. PM
Blair knew this very well, for one of his first acts in government (3 May 1997)
was to use the Council to make the Civil Service subordinate to spin doctors https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/247039/response/605821/attach/3/3%20May%201997%20Civil%20Service%20Amendment%20Order%20in%20Council%201997.pdf?cookie_passthrough=1.
The Opposition in Parliament is our safeguard against
tyranny, but it has failed. A touchstone for this is the way that on 19 October
last year Parliament renewed the extraordinary powers of the Coronavirus Act
without so much as a division. https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/watch-mps-extend-the-coronavirus-act-without-a-vote
The Covid episode has taught the State that there is almost nothing it cannot
do to the people, provided the Opposition colludes in the hope of getting their
turn soon and the Fourth Estate sings loyally from the State’s hymn sheet. We
see this again in Canada, where Prime Minister Trudeau has invoked emergency
powers merely to deal with trucker protests he himself has provoked by his high-handed
Covid mandates.
Even the American Presidency is tending towards autocracy –
remember how back in September Biden, speaking to his country about the Covid
vaccination program, said ‘this is not about freedom or personal choice… my job
as President is to protect all Americans… we’ve been patient, but our patience
is wearing thin.’ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7chQfQ67SM
There as here, government has invaded our daily life so far that the new wine
of super-power threatens to burst the old skins of restraining constitutional
arrangements; for example, President Biden’s role is set down in Article Two of
the Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Two_of_the_United_States_Constitution
and there his protection was defined in military, rather than medical terms.
If the US were committed to genuine democracy, the
Republicans would not find so many ways to make it harder for the underclass to
participate in elections – redrawing constituency boundaries into fantastical politically-motivated
shapes, siting polling stations far from left-voting population centres and so
on; and the Democrats would not be turning a blind eye to, if not encouraging, an
influx of poor immigrants whose ballots they hope may be counted on for a
generation, or even allowing non-citizens the right to vote. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jan/09/new-york-allows-non-citizens-vote-controversial-law
It is hard to escape the conclusion that the real theme of
what is happening domestically and internationally is simply the acquisition,
concentration and retention of power. Former President Carter’s foreign policy
adviser Zbigniew Brzeziński reflected on this in his book ‘The Grand
Chessboard: American Primacy and Its Geostrategic Imperatives,’ https://www.cia.gov/library/abbottabad-compound/36/36669B7894E857AC4F3445EA646BFFE1_Zbigniew_Brzezinski_-_The_Grand_ChessBoard.doc.pdf
published in 1997 - five years after the
Soviet collapse. In this work, the term ‘freedom’ appears ten times, ‘democracy’
25 times but ‘hegemon/y’ 56 times; what he calls ‘the game’ is played out using
a string of ‘perches’ for American forces around the globe.
Brzeziński worried that the EU might become more independent
of US influence, even friendly with Russia:
‘… any ejection of America by its
Western partners from its perch on the western periphery would automatically spell
the end of America's participation in the game on the Eurasian chessboard, even
though that would probably also mean the eventual subordination of the western
extremity to a revived player occupying the middle space.’
Well, here we are, 25 years on.
In playing this real-life board game – more like Risk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_(game)
than chess – I think our leaders have lost the plot. What good will it do us?
For it is ‘the economy, stupid.’ After a decade (the 1950s)
in which the Soviet economy had been growing twice as fast as Britain’s, PM
Harold Macmillan wrote (December 1960) to President Kennedy:
‘What is going to happen to us
unless we can show that our modern free society – the new form of capitalism –
can make the fullest use of our resources and results in a steady expansion of
our economic strength… If we fail in this, Communism will triumph, not by war,
or even subversion, but by seeming to be a better way of bringing people
material comforts. In other words, if we were to fall back into anything like
the recession or crisis that we had between the wars, with large-scale
unemployment of men and machines, I think we would have lost the hand.’
- Quoted in ‘Macmillan: The Official
Biography’ by Alistair Horne (Macmillan, 1988)
For me the word that stands out there is ‘new’; capitalism
old-style and protected by a very limited franchise was what fuelled the
indignation that threatened to tear apart our ‘free society’; Lloyd George was
forced to emasculate the House of lords in order to advance even his relatively
modest welfare reforms.
Despite universal adult suffrage in the UK (still awaiting
its centenary) the economic strains have begun to return as Western elites gave
globalist bankers and traders their head. The tensions this has created at home
are now being contained with high-handed government and unprecedented data-driven
spying on and suppression of the people, abetted by an Opposition whose
principal concern is its own welfare, and a complaisant mass media.
It’s not the Russians we need to sort out.
Saturday, February 19, 2022
WEEKENDER: Kamila Valieva - a Pawn in the Game? by Wiggia
The young Russian figure skater caught out in the Olympics for drug use is currently getting a soft ride from both the IOC and the press. It cannot be a coincidence that her age is a factor in all this and the fact she is currently the world's Number One in her sport.
Should we care? Sport in general has not covered itself with glory when it comes to tackling difficult issues, such as footballers who insist taking the knee is a worthwhile practice, when the BLM is being exposed as an organisation that not only has ulterior motives away from race but is also a launching pad for the founders to fleece the public funds coming their way... millionaire row beckons.
Yet the players in our PL carry on as if this totally misguided gesture is actually having an effect on perceived racism, when in fact telling everyone every week they are racist just creates resentment for something that has been in decline for years; now, thanks to their agitation, it is headline news again.
It is and has been said that sport and politics do not mix, though the truth is politicians have used sport to their advantage for decades, and the fundamental principles of the Olympics as laid out by Pierre de Coubertin in 1898 have been jettisoned in favour of a flag-waving exercise. The Olympic movement is all about money and more of it, the amount poured into the IOC coffers to seal an Olympic bid are proof of that.
Nations and politicians all want to bask in the glory of having spent more than the last Games or World Cup to seal their place in history. The coming World Cup in Qatar has to be one of the most ridiculous decisions by a sporting body in history: a country that has no interest in any sport other than importing a few Africans to boost their non-existent medal tally has only political reasons to bid for a major sporting event.
The truth about how the stadiums have been built with the equivalent of slave labour with a death rate that has been deliberately hidden away was revealed very early on but ignored by FIFA and all the countries competing including our own kneeling team; the manager who believes kneeling sends the ‘right message’ is very quiet about competing in Qatar - why could that possibly be?
When one looks back to the fuss about touring cricket teams during the apartheid years in South Africa and the banning of players who competed there, today's attitude reveals a gap in moral fortitude the width of the Grand Canyon. The difference is money: no money for a breakaway cricket tour in real terms, but huge amounts gained in Qatar.
It was ever thus.
Back to Valieva. The sympathy being shown to the young Russian who is competing with a faux Russian team with the name ROC - a pseudonym for loophole - is being seen in a very different light to those young east Germans years ago, part of the regime's systematic doping program. Russia along with China has been doing the same thing in recent times, not that the USA or others have clean hands in all this during the same period.
Having failed a drug test she should have been automatically excluded from competing. It matters not if she was coerced, though the route to fame and fortune often does not need much coercion; she failed a test and that should have been that. If she wins now, we will now have the sight of other athletes being denied their rightful place on the podium and another sport being forever tainted.
This is the IOCs wording on anyone caught doping in competition at Beijing:
'An anti-doping rule violation in Individual Sports in connection with an In-Competition test automatically leads to Disqualification of the result obtained in that Competition with all resulting Consequences, including forfeiture of any medals, diplomas, points and prizes.'
You would think from that it is pretty cut and dried, but apparently not. They do themselves no favours in using weasel words to allow Valieva to continue.
Coming from a cycling background, I am more than aware of how doping ruins sport, and have written on the subject in a different context before. There is little doubt all sports have indulged in forms of doping. Lax testing and a reluctance to match other sports' doping regimes has allowed hitherto ‘clean’ sports to prosper whereas under the surface it has been going on for years.
Allowing this young girl to compete, along with some decisions deserving of derision in the USA regarding endless numbers of sprinters being found to fail drugs tests yet re-appearing months later in competition, has resulted in empty stadiums. When all sports become tainted with the belief that ‘everyone is at it’ sport loses its value in society. Fraudulent behaviour in sport should never be seen as different from fraud in the wider world, and whether the fifteen-year-old girl was used or was aware of being doped is of no consequence, she should not be there; it perpetuates the whole ‘winning at all costs' mentality that pervades sport these days when money is king.
Also, we must never forget the long term effects that doping has on competitors in many cases, including deaths. During the EPO (Armstrong) era many cyclists died after blood clotting events caused by the drug; again, the real numbers were not issued officially as far as I know, but it was not merely one or two, and again athletes as young as fifteen / fourteen were testing positive. Somehow though, I cannot see it ever being eradicated. Gene therapy is already being touted as the next challenge and we cannot be sure it is not already being trialled; this is very complicated to test for and prove though no doubt in the future it will be possible, but yet again it continues the drug era into the foreseeable future. Money and drugs will always triumph over morals in sport, it seems; a sad indictment of our times.
An article in the Times shows the hypocrisy among national sporting bodies. This runner has just retired:
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/3e0da814-8f43-11ec-9569-fea923928840?shareToken=2232a4d7cd091518051881a6143f9661
As this article is normally behind a paywall and I read it as part of my ‘free’ sampler I offer you this passage, which sets the tone:
'The US Olympic Committee was understandably disgruntled with the outcome of Kamila Valieva’s case at the Winter Olympics in Beijing. She is only 15, a “protected person” according to the World Anti-Doping Agency, and the latest chapter in Russia’s flagrant abuse of sporting ethics. However, that US Track & Field saw fit to post an image of Justin Gatlin alongside a starry-eyed emoji and the words: “Happy retirement to one of the greatest!” highlighted Olympic levels of hypocrisy as we sank further in the murk.'